
Introduction
This is our case study interview with Tokyo Prize Agency Co., Ltd. ("Tenro-in Bookstore"), which runs Tenro-in Bookstore, a next-generation café with many fans across Japan.
Tenro-in Bookstore previously ran its online store on WordPress, customized with plugins, but it supported only a few payment methods, and the conversion rate was a challenge. With a low conversion rate, sales from promotions such as web advertising naturally didn't grow as hoped, and it was hard to run the PDCA cycle.
To solve these issues, they considered a platform migration and asked us to take it on. In 2023, we built the site on Shopify, expanded the payment methods that come with it and helped connect Shopify with Facebook ads, among other work. In this interview, Nonaka, who led the build at Hiyaku, spoke with Torii, the person in charge at Tenro-in Bookstore, about the benefits of switching to Shopify.
Nonaka:
It's been a while. Thank you for joining us today.
Torii:
It's been a while. Ask me anything.
Nonaka:
Let's get right to it. How has it been after running the store for a year?
Torii:
We struggled in the early days after the migration, but by now we've gotten used to adding products to the site.
I'm happy to talk about how it's working in practice, too.
Contents
About Tenro-in Bookstore
—First, please tell us about Tenro-in Bookstore's business.
Torii:
As the name suggests, we offer a range of services centered on books, and our concept is "offering books, and the experiences that lie beyond them." Specifically, we run learning courses taught by professionals in fields such as AI, design, photography, video and writing. Most courses are taken at our stores, but some can be taken online.
We have stores in Shibuya, Shonan, Nagoya, Kyoto and Fukuoka. Many people use them as more than just bookstores: they are "places for learning and meeting people," where visitors not only pick up and read books but also boost their creativity by sharing experiences and knowledge.
—You offer a paid membership service. How do you run it?
Torii:
Our paid membership is priced from ¥11,000 a month, and we use a Shopify-compatible subscription app. With this app, the monthly fee is charged automatically at the start of each month.
—The learning course market seems like a red ocean, yet your paid membership keeps growing. Why do you think membership is increasing?
Torii:
I think the biggest reason is that our courses are highly reproducible. When people take a course, it isn't the kind of thing where they think, "Well, only a top professional like so-and-so could do that." The content is designed with reproducibility in mind, so that if you study properly and put it into practice, you will gain the skills. Customers are satisfied with that, and it leads to repeat enrollments, so that's our greatest strength.

★Writing seminar featured on ABEMA Prime, broadcast Thursday, June 9, 2022.
Taken by more than 9,000 people in total
There are also two other basic benefits of becoming a paid member. The first is that members can purchase courses and books at discounted prices. Our paid members are very satisfied with the courses and books we offer, and with the discounts, their annual learning costs often end up lower than those of regular members.
The second is that each member is assigned a dedicated staff member. Through ongoing communication with that person, we fully support members' skill development after the courses. Another major benefit is that the dedicated staff member not only offers advice but can also share the latest information on building skills.
Why they migrated the online store
—What led you to consider renewing the site this time?
Torii:
Our top mission was to maximize the return on our advertising spend.
WordPress doesn't come with analytics features by default, and we struggled to analyze things like ad-driven sales and average order value, which made it hard to plan initiatives.
Also, for security and other reasons, PayPal was the only payment method we offered. Because buyers were limited to PayPal users, even when we tried to increase ad-driven sales, there was a barrier: customers couldn't pay with the method they wanted.
Shopify supports a wide range of payment methods and comes with analytics features by default, so it solves those fundamental problems, and it also integrates smoothly with the online store. Considering how much easier it would make ad management, we decided to move to Shopify.
—What results have you seen since the renewal?
Torii:
With the move to Shopify, we added a variety of new payment methods, including credit cards, Amazon Pay and Paidy. As a result, we now offer far more payment options, and convenience for customers has improved dramatically. We've heard from many customers that the store has become easier to use, and sales are growing steadily.
Using Shopify's store analytics, we can now see data such as sales, sessions and click-through rates in real time. This lets us optimize ad campaigns as we go, and cost-effectiveness improved dramatically right after we started operating the new store. By accurately understanding ad performance and running the PDCA cycle quickly, we've been able, to a certain extent, to operate in a way that maximizes return on investment.
—You use a subscription app to collect membership fees. How do operations compare with before?
Torii:
Running the paid membership has improved a lot. With the old cart, we used PayPal's recurring payment feature, but customers could cancel their subscriptions themselves, so it was hard to keep an accurate count of members, and management was complicated. Also, without going into detail, the product page UI on the old site had issues, which led to many incorrect orders.
Since moving to Shopify, we've restricted customers from canceling subscriptions on their own, so it's now very easy to see how many paid members we have and how many each staff member is responsible for.
The UI has also become cleaner, and I think the UX has improved too, for example by controlling discounts based on whether someone is a member and showing the appropriate guidance in a pop-up.
Building the online store
—What was the hardest part of building the Shopify site?
Torii:
Product registration was the hardest part. Each product has different selling points, and what we wanted to do couldn't be expressed with uniform product pages. So, to give each product its own page elements and display order, we had to go to the trouble of creating a large number of product page templates. There may have been a better way, but with limited time and money, we went with the best approach we could think of at the time.
Still, because we put in that effort, it's great that we can now edit page content almost entirely without code using Shopify's graphical user interface.
Nonaka:
—I was really impressed that you registered all of your several hundred products in about two weeks (laughs).
Torii:
That's right (laughs).
The schedule to launch was tight, but you gave us very thorough support. I really appreciated that you even gave us hands-on training.
Of course we communicated over chat, but we also always had a regular meeting once a week, so I could ask about anything I didn't understand right when it came up.
It was also a big help that you recorded the training sessions on Zoom. We couldn't do all the work during the meetings, so being able to work while watching the training videos was much appreciated.
Nonaka:
You're too kind (laughs nervously).

A look at one of our actual meetings
Running the online store
—About a year has passed since you renewed the online store. Apart from more payment methods and better ad cost-effectiveness, is there anything else that's been good about moving to Shopify?
Torii:
There are three main things. The first is that we can use the Buy Button.
We put a lot of effort into content such as our blog, which we still run on the old site. By placing a Buy Button at the bottom of each blog post, readers are taken straight to the Shopify checkout page, so the UX is seamless, and we've found that even though customers are actually moving between sites, they're very unlikely to drop off.
The second is a bit technical: the structure of product data and how it's reflected in the UI.
We run each course on multiple dates at multiple stores, so a single course ends up with a huge number of combinations. With the old cart, we embedded a separate PayPal payment button for each combination on the product page, so the buttons were lined up in long rows, and the UI wasn't very easy to read. It wasn't that we wanted it that way; the cart's specifications left us no choice, and registering everything was also very tedious.
On Shopify, we organize that information using product variants, and a single add-to-cart button is enough on the page, so we can give more space to the information we most want to highlight, and I think customers can proceed to checkout smoothly.
Finally, the third is the built-in store analytics.
Beyond the usual sales, sessions and conversion rates, Shopify also offers analysis of information that's important for running a store but that you rarely get elsewhere, such as customer data and the sell-out status of inventory, all included for free, which has been very useful.
—Your president, Miura, even upgraded your plan to get richer store analytics (laughs).
Torii:
That's right. Even now, we analyze what's selling together with our staff.

Summary of an analytics report available in Shopify
—You mentioned the Buy Button earlier. Is purchasing from the blog your main traffic channel?
Torii:
Yes. We've been writing the blog for a very long time, so we have a core fan base. I feel it's very helpful when these readers sign up for courses or buy products. Going forward, we'd like to look closely at metrics such as their purchase rate.
Final thoughts
—Please tell us what you'd like to achieve with Shopify going forward.
Torii:
Not so much with Shopify specifically, but as an online store, we want to keep refining how we present our products so we can better convey their appeal to customers.
As I said at the start, the appeal of our products lies in how reproducible and immediately applicable the learning is, and we want to communicate that more clearly to grow course enrollment. To do that, I think we need to provide more information about the courses and instructors, and although it still needs consideration, making use of reviews could also be important information for people who are thinking about starting to learn.
We also want to increase touchpoints with customers through email newsletters and CRM initiatives. Behind our service concept of "offering books, and the experiences that lie beyond them" is the hope that people will keep on learning. And so that people can connect with the value we offer, "places for learning and meeting people," we want to regularly share information about such opportunities and grow our community.
Learning only means something when you keep at it, and we are committed to building a service where people who have taken our courses can connect in positive ways with those who are considering them.